The Fire in the East

A Surprising New Wildfire Threat Emerges

New research reveals a startling trend—wildfires are occurring with greater frequency in the eastern United States, posing potentially greater risks due to higher population density.

Introduction

When we imagine wildfires, our minds typically conjure images of the American West—the sprawling, drought-parched landscapes of California, Oregon, and Colorado, where massive blazes dominate headlines. But a quiet, equally concerning threat is igniting where few expected it: in the lush, seemingly fire-resistant forests of the eastern United States.

New research reveals a startling trend—wildfires are not only occurring with greater frequency in the East but also pose a potentially greater risk to human life due to the region's higher population density.

This shift represents a fundamental change in our understanding of wildfire ecology and threat assessment, forcing scientists, policymakers, and communities to confront a danger that was largely overlooked. The story of fire in the East is one of ecological imbalance, human intervention, and a pressing need to re-learn the ancient relationship between flame and forest.

2X

Increase in large wildfires in the East since 2005

85%

Of eastern wildfires are human-caused

56%

Of U.S. population lives in eastern and southern regions

A System Out of Balance: The Era of Fire Suppression

For thousands of years, fire was a constant and essential architect of eastern landscapes. Before European settlement, diverse arrays of fire-adapted plant communities covered the region, from the tallgrass prairies to the vast oak-pine forests 6 . These were largely pyrogenic systems—ecosystems that assembled under and were maintained by recurrent fire.

Historical Role of Fire

Native American tribes actively managed these environments with fire; they were, in the words of ecologists, a "keystone species" in this context, using controlled burns to improve hunting, shape the land, and maintain open, park-like forests 6 7 .

Fire Suppression Era

Beginning around the 1920s, the official stance became that all fire was an enemy to be defeated 6 . This policy was initially successful but had unforeseen ecological consequences.

What is Mesophication?

Mesophication is a positive feedback cycle initiated by fire suppression that ecologists Gregory Nowacki and Marc Abrams have termed the driving force behind eastern forest changes 6 .

Without Fire

Open, sun-drenched ("heliophytic") lands quickly convert to closed-canopy forests.

Dense Canopy Forms

The dense canopy creates cool, damp, and shaded conditions on the forest floor.

Species Shift

These conditions are ideal for shade-tolerant, fire-sensitive species (like maple and beech) but deteriorate for shade-intolerant, fire-adapted species (like oak and pine).

Reduced Flammability

The resulting forest develops less flammable fuel beds, making it harder for fire to spread and further reinforcing the new, fire-intolerant system.

The result is a rapid and ongoing homogenization of the landscape. Stand-level species richness is declining as numerous fire-adapted plants are replaced by a limited set of shade-tolerant, fire-sensitive species. The ecosystems we see today in the East are, in many cases, undergoing rapid changes with no ecological antecedent 6 .

A Conclusive Experiment: Tracking the Eastern Fire Trend

For years, anecdotal evidence suggested fires were becoming more common in the East, but a pivotal scientific study provided the hard data to confirm this alarming shift.

Methodology: A 36-Year Data Analysis

Published in Geophysical Research Letters, a team of researchers led by ecologist Victoria Donovan undertook a comprehensive analysis of wildfire data across the eastern United States over a 36-year period 3 .

The study compared two distinct time periods: the two decades prior to 2005 and the years from 2005 to 2018. The goal was to identify whether wildfires were growing in frequency and scope, not just as a result of random bad years, but as a sustained trend.

Results and Analysis: A Clear and Present Danger

The study's findings were stark. The data showed that large wildfire numbers had doubled in the 2005-2018 period compared to the two decades prior 3 . This was not a minor fluctuation.

The increase was attributed to climate change, fuel proliferation, invasive species, and human ignition sources.

Regional Wildfire Increases

Southern Coastal Plains

Significant increases in Florida, coastal Georgia, and South Carolina 3

Central Appalachian Mountains

Notable increases in Tennessee, West Virginia, and Virginia 3

Northeastern U.S.

Decreases, linked to shifting climatic conditions and more precipitation 3

Primary Causes of Eastern Wildfires

The Scientist's Toolkit: Essentials for Fire Ecology and Management

Restoring healthy fire regimes and studying wildfire behavior requires a specific set of tools and knowledge.

Prescribed Fire

A planned fire used to meet specific management objectives, such as reducing hazardous fuels, restoring fire-adapted ecosystems, and managing wildlife habitat .

Fire Scar Analysis

The study of scars left on trees by past fires. This is a primary method for understanding historical fire regimes, including their frequency and severity 6 .

Cultural Burning

The continued practice of Indigenous fire stewardship, recognized as a critical tool for maintaining specific habitats like coastal prairies and oak savannas .

Advanced Vegetation Mapping

Geospatial data layers used by ecologists to map past and current fire regimes and vegetation types across large scales, helping to quantify changes 6 .

Effectiveness of Fire Management Tools

A New Kind of Danger: Why Eastern Wildfires Are Different

The wildfires menacing the East may not burn the same vast acreage as their western counterparts, but they present a unique and potentially deadlier set of risks.

The core of the danger lies in the wildland-urban interface (WUI)—the zone where houses and wildland vegetation intermingle 3 . The eastern and southern United States are far more densely populated than the West; 56% of the U.S. population lives in these regions, compared to just 24% in the West 3 .

This population density creates a "double whammy" of risk 3 . First, when a fire ignites, it immediately threatens a greater number of people and homes, making it harder to defend property and safely evacuate residents. Second, the presence of more people directly increases the likelihood of ignitions, both accidental and intentional.

Western U.S. Wildfires
  • Primary Driver: Climate and drought (fuel-limited)
  • Population Density: Lower 3
  • WUI: Extensive, but often less dense 3
  • Example: Camp Fire (153,336 acres, 85 deaths) 3
Eastern U.S. Wildfires
  • Primary Driver: Human activity and fuel buildup (ignition-limited) 3
  • Population Density: Higher 3
  • WUI: Very extensive and densely populated 3
  • Example: Gatlinburg Fire (~17,000 acres, 14 deaths, 2,500 structures) 3
The Gatlinburg Fire Case Study

The devastating 2016 Gatlinburg fire in Tennessee serves as a tragic case study. Although the fire was less than a tenth the size of California's infamous Camp Fire, it destroyed nearly 2,500 structures and killed 14 people 3 . This event illustrated with terrible clarity that the scale of a disaster is not measured in acres alone, but in the proximity of flame to community. The East, with its extensive WUI, is uniquely vulnerable to this type of tragedy.

The Path Forward: Restoring Fire's Rightful Role

Confronting the rising threat of eastern wildfires requires a paradigm shift. The strategy cannot be simply to double down on suppression—that was the policy that created the current crisis.

Instead, the solution lies in reintroducing fire to the landscape in a careful, controlled, and informed way.

Prescribed Burning

Dramatically scaling up the use of prescribed burning to reduce the dangerous fuel loads that have accumulated over decades of suppression 6 .

Cultural Burning

Embracing cultural burning practices and the deep ecological knowledge held by Indigenous communities 7 .

Community Planning

Developing sophisticated evacuation plans and implementing fire-wise landscaping codes for homes in the WUI.

Projected Benefits of Fire Management Strategies

The challenge is immense, but the cost of inaction is even greater. As the mesophication process continues, the effort and expense required to restore fire-adapted ecosystems escalate rapidly 6 . The "Fire in the East" is no longer a distant theory; it is a present-day reality. How we choose to respond will determine the safety of communities and the health of eastern forests for generations to come.

The phoenix of legend was reborn from its own ashes; our task is to learn how to tend the fire so that our forests and communities can also rise, resilient and renewed.

References

References